CLOUDS & WEATHER VALID 06 NOV 1800Z
Illustration
VFR on top vs VFR over the top: US and Canadian rules
US VFR-on-top is an IFR clearance. Canada's VFR OTT needs a rating and a destination forecast check. Five similar terms, their rules, and a worked TAF check.
13 min read
“VFR on top” sounds like one idea. It is five. In the US, VFR-on-top is an IFR clearance, and VFR over-the-top is plain VFR above a layer. In Canada, VFR OTT is a VFR flight that needs a rating and a forecast check at the destination. Canada also has an IFR procedure called “at least 1 000-ft-on-top”, and it does not allow the American VFR-on-top (TC AIM RAC 8.7). Europe has its own VFR on top.
All five are special cases of the VFR and IFR flight rules. This guide sets them side by side, each with its source, then checks a destination TAF the Canadian way.
Five terms that sound alike
| Term | Where | What it is | Who may fly it | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| VFR OTT | Canada | VFR above cloud, by day, in cruise, with a destination forecast test | A licence with a VFR OTT rating, or an instrument rating | CARs 602.116, 401.45, 401.47 |
| At least 1,000-ft-on-top | Canada | IFR, at least 1,000 ft above all cloud and other formations, authorized by ATC | Pilots on IFR flights | TC AIM RAC 8.7 |
| VFR-on-top | US | IFR, on an IFR flight plan, cleared to maintain “VFR conditions on top”. Not allowed in Canadian Domestic Airspace | Pilots with an instrument rating or an airline transport pilot certificate | 14 CFR 1.1, 61.3(e), 91.179(a); TC AIM RAC 8.7 |
| VFR over-the-top | US | VFR above the layer that forms the ceiling, with the normal VFR minimums | No rating needed; not student, recreational or sport pilots | 14 CFR 1.1, 61.89(a)(7), 91.155 |
| VFR on top | EASA | VFR above cloud, higher than the band where SERA asks for the surface in sight | VFR flights; SERA names no rating for it | SERA.5001, GM1 SERA.5005(c)(3)(iii) |
Transport Canada says it plainly: “Despite being similar sounding, the following standards and clearances are not the same and must not be confused” (TC AIM RAC 8.7). Its list has VFR OTT, “at least 1 000 ft-on-top” and the American VFR-on-top.
US VFR-on-top: an IFR clearance
Transport Canada calls it “the American VFR-on-top” (TC AIM RAC 8.7). In 14 CFR, it is IFR over-the-top: “the operation of an aircraft over-the-top on an IFR flight plan when cleared by air traffic control to maintain ‘VFR conditions’ or ‘VFR conditions on top’” (14 CFR 1.1). Over-the-top means “above the layer of clouds or other obscuring phenomena forming the ceiling” (1.1).
- You stay IFR. The flight is on an IFR flight plan. To act as pilot in command under IFR, you need an instrument rating or an airline transport pilot certificate (14 CFR 61.3(e)).
- You fly a VFR altitude. In controlled airspace, when the clearance assigns “VFR conditions on-top”, you “shall maintain an altitude or flight level as prescribed by § 91.159” (14 CFR 91.179(a)). Section 91.159 is the VFR cruising altitude rule: see VFR cruising altitudes.
- It stops at the border. Canada does not allow it in Canadian Domestic Airspace (TC AIM RAC 8.7).
US VFR over-the-top: plain VFR above a layer
“VFR over-the-top, with respect to the operation of aircraft, means the operation of an aircraft over-the-top under VFR when it is not being operated on an IFR flight plan” (14 CFR 1.1).
- No rating. 14 CFR 61.5(b) lists the US ratings. None of them is for over-the-top flight.
- Normal VFR minimums. The flight visibility and distance from cloud of 14 CFR 91.155 apply to every VFR flight, above a layer too. The VFR weather minimums guide has the table.
- Not for every pilot. A student pilot may not act as pilot in command “When the flight cannot be made with visual reference to the surface” (14 CFR 61.89(a)(7)). A recreational pilot (61.101(e)(10)) and a sport pilot (61.315(c)(13)) may not fly “Without visual reference to the surface”.
Canada VFR OTT: the weather rules (CARs 602.116)
A VFR flight in Canada must keep visual reference to the surface. It is condition (a) in controlled airspace and in uncontrolled airspace: “the aircraft is operated with visual reference to the surface” (CARs 602.114 and 602.115).
VFR OTT is the exception. CARs 602.116 opens: “Despite paragraphs 602.114(a) and 602.115(a), an aircraft may be operated in VFR OTT flight during the cruise portion of the flight during the day if” four conditions are met.
| What | Rule | 602.116 |
|---|---|---|
| Distance from cloud | At least 1,000 ft vertically | (a) |
| Between two layers | The layers at least 5,000 ft apart | (b) |
| Flight visibility at your cruising altitude | At least 5 miles | (c) |
| Destination forecast | The test below | (d) |
Two limits come before the numbers:
- By day. In the CARs, day is “the time between the beginning of morning civil twilight” and “the end of evening civil twilight” (CARs 101.01). The guide when night starts shows how to find those times.
- Cruise only. The exception covers “the cruise portion of the flight”. You climb and descend under the normal VFR rules, with visual reference to the surface.
The destination forecast test
Paragraph (d), word for word:
(d) the weather at the aerodrome of destination is forecast to have no broken, overcast or obscured layer lower than 3,000 feet above the planned flight altitude and the ground visibility is forecast to be five miles or greater with no thunderstorms or precipitation
(i) where the forecast is an aerodrome forecast (TAF), for the period from one hour before to two hours after the estimated time of arrival, using the worst forecast condition together with any of the references TEMPO (temporary fluctuation), BECMG (becoming) or PROB (probability), and
(ii) where an aerodrome forecast (TAF) is not available and the forecast is an area forecast (FA), for the period from one hour before to three hours after the estimated time of arrival.
In practice, that is four checks:
- The window. With a TAF, from 1 hour before to 2 hours after your ETA. With no TAF, the area forecast, from 1 hour before to 3 hours after.
- The worst case. Use the worst condition in the window, together with every TEMPO, BECMG and PROB group in it. A PROB30 counts.
- Visibility and weather. The forecast ground visibility is 5 miles or more, with no thunderstorms and no precipitation.
- Cloud. No broken, overcast or obscured layer “lower than 3,000 feet above the planned flight altitude”.
This guide does not interpret the cloud check or give a number for it. Ask Transport Canada or your flight instructor how it applies to your flight.
The CARs still say “area forecast (FA)”. The TC AIM summary says “area forecast (GFA)” (RAC 2.7.4): the GFA guide explains that chart. The two fields I fly from, CSE4 and CSB3, have no weather report. In Canada, “TAFs are limited to aerodromes for which METAR and SPECI reports are available” (TC AIM MET 1.3.3), so they have no TAF either. A VFR OTT flight to one of them would use (ii) and its 3-hour window.
On the radio. “Pilots should indicate that the flight is VFR OTT during communications with ATS units” (TC AIM RAC 2.7.4). The position report format that the TC AIM recommends for a flight information centre has a “VFR / VFR-OTT” item (RAC 5.1).
Canada VFR OTT rating
“The holder of a licence that has been endorsed with a VFR OTT rating may exercise the privileges of the licence in VFR OTT flight in accordance with section 602.116” (CARs 401.45).
| VFR OTT rating | |
|---|---|
| Licences it goes on | Private pilot licence, aeroplane or helicopter; commercial and airline transport pilot licences, helicopter (CARs 401.44) |
| Experience | At least 15 hours of dual instrument time, of which up to 5 hours may be instrument ground time (Standard 421.44(3)) |
| Knowledge and skill | To the Flight Instructor Standard - VFR OTT (Standard 421.44(2) and (4)) |
| Exam and flight test | “There is no flight test or written examination for the VFR OTT rating” (TP 12775, TC instructor guide, 1996). Standard 421.44 lists neither |
| How it is endorsed | The instructor recommends you on the form “Flight Crew Licence — Application for Endorsement of a Rating” (TP 12775) |
| With an instrument rating | Included: the instrument rating gives “the privileges accorded by a VFR OTT rating” (CARs 401.47(b)). A holder gets the VFR OTT rating “upon request” (Standard 421.44(5)) |
The instrument rating in Canada guide covers the larger rating.
The aircraft. “No person shall conduct a take-off in a power-driven aircraft for the purpose of VFR OTT flight unless it is equipped with” (CARs 605.15(1)):
- the equipment of 605.14(c) to (j);
- a sensitive altimeter adjustable for barometric pressure;
- a means of preventing malfunction caused by icing for each airspeed indicating system;
- a gyroscopic direction indicator or a stabilized magnetic direction indicator;
- an attitude indicator;
- a turn and slip indicator or turn coordinator (a slip-skid indicator is allowed with a third attitude indicator, 605.15(2));
- in the Northern Domestic Airspace, a means of establishing direction that is not dependent on a magnetic source;
- two-way radio on the appropriate frequency;
- radio navigation equipment adequate to navigate the aircraft safely.
Note: the TC AIM summary uses the old rule
The TC AIM (RAC 2.7.4, edition of October 1, 2026) gives “a summary of the minima” of CAR 602.116. Its destination item still follows the old paragraph (d), the version in force until June 13, 2019. SOR/2019-119 replaced that wording from June 14, 2019.
| TC AIM RAC 2.7.4 (the summary) | CARs 602.116(d) (the regulation) | |
|---|---|---|
| Sky at the destination | “scattered cloud or clear” | No broken, overcast or obscured layer lower than 3,000 ft above the planned flight altitude |
| Weather at the destination | No forecast of “precipitation, fog, thunderstorms, or blowing snow” | No thunderstorms or precipitation |
| Ground visibility | 5 mi. or more | Five miles or greater |
| TEMPO, BECMG, PROB | Not named | The worst forecast condition, together with any TEMPO, BECMG or PROB |
| No TAF | Area forecast (GFA), 1 h before to 3 h after the ETA | Area forecast (FA), 1 h before to 3 h after the ETA |
The summary is not the rule. Plan with the CARs text. The Regulatory Impact Analysis Statement of SOR/2019-119 says the new paragraph (d) will “reflect the original intent of the Visual Flight Rules Over-the-Top requirements”, with accepted terms such as TEMPO, BECMG and PROB.
Canada “at least 1,000-ft-on-top” (IFR)
This one is IFR. TC AIM RAC 8.7 allows it when:
- the flight is at least 1,000 ft above all cloud, haze, smoke or other formation;
- the flight visibility above the formation is at least 3 miles;
- the top of the formation is well defined;
- the altitude for the direction of flight is kept in level cruise;
- the appropriate ATC unit has authorized it;
- the aircraft stays in Class B airspace at or below 12,500 ft ASL, or in Class C, D or E airspace.
“ATC does not apply separation to aircraft operating at least 1 000-ft-on-top” (RAC 8.7). There are two exceptions: at night when any of the aircraft are holding, and against an aircraft on an altitude reservation.
EASA: VFR on top
By day, SERA asks for the surface in sight only low down. In classes F and G, at and below 3,000 ft AMSL or 1,000 ft above terrain, whichever is higher, the distance from cloud is “Clear of cloud and with the surface in sight” (SERA.5001, Table S5-1, EASA Easy Access Rules). Above that band, the table asks for flight visibility and distance from cloud only. The VFR weather minimums guide has those numbers.
At night, VFR flights “may be permitted” only “When so prescribed by the competent authority” (SERA.5005(c)). In classes B to G, at and below 3,000 ft AMSL or 1,000 ft above terrain, whichever is higher, “the pilot shall maintain continuous sight of the surface” (SERA.5005(c)(3)(iii)). Above that, EASA’s guidance material on night VFR on top says “the pilot may elect to fly above a cloud layer (VFR on top)” (GM1 SERA.5005(c)(3)(iii)). It lists what to weigh first:
- whether the destination weather will allow a descent in visual conditions;
- the lighting below and above the layer;
- if you stay below instead, a cloud base that comes down and takes your terrain clearance;
- layers that converge above the cloud;
- whether you can turn back to where you keep the surface in sight;
- whether you can fix your position all along the route, with the terrain and obstacles.
That list is a good one for any flight on top, by day or by night. Note the contrast: Canadian VFR OTT is by day only. To fly through the layer instead of over it, you need IFR privileges: the EASA instrument rating guide covers the routes.
Worked example: checking a destination TAF
You plan a VFR OTT flight by day from Montréal / St-Hubert (CYHU) to Québec / Jean Lesage (CYQB). The GFA shows an overcast layer over the middle of the route, with tops near 6,000 ft. Both ends are outside it. Here is the destination TAF. It is a real-format example, written for this guide, not a real forecast. If the codes are new to you, read how to read a TAF first.
Your ETA is 15:00Z (10:00 EST).
- The window runs from 14:00Z to 17:00Z (602.116(d)(i)).
- The groups in the window are the main forecast,
P6SM SCT040, andTEMPO 0614/0617 4SM -SHRA BKN030. - The worst case is 4 SM in light rain showers. 4 SM is less than 5 miles, and showers are precipitation.
VFR OTT to CYQB fails at this ETA, even though the main forecast is more than 6 SM with scattered cloud. The rule uses the worst condition together with the TEMPO group.
The same TAF gives other answers at other times:
| ETA | Window | Groups in the window | Worst visibility and weather | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 15:00Z (10:00 EST) | 14:00Z to 17:00Z | Main forecast, TEMPO 0614/0617 |
4 SM, light rain showers | Fails |
| 19:00Z (14:00 EST) | 18:00Z to 21:00Z | FM061800 only |
More than 6 SM, no weather | The test in (d) is met |
| 21:00Z (16:00 EST) | 20:00Z to 23:00Z | FM061800, PROB30 0622/0702 |
2 SM, light rain showers | Fails: the PROB30 counts |
At 19:00Z, the window holds only FM061800 29012KT P6SM FEW050. It has no broken, overcast or obscured layer at all, so the cloud check has nothing to catch, whatever your planned altitude. The en-route conditions (a) to (c) are still yours to keep in flight.
At 21:00Z, the main forecast in the window is good, but the PROB30 group starts at 22:00Z, inside the window. Here is the same TAF with that window marked:
The ETA matters. If you leave 90 minutes late on the 19:00Z plan and arrive at 20:30Z, the window runs to 22:30Z. It now holds the PROB30 group, and the check fails. Check again with your real ETA before you climb on top. All these arrivals are by day: civil dusk at CYQB is at about 16:55 EST that day (computed with the NOAA equations).
The colours on the timeline are flight categories. They come from the ceiling and the visibility only, and they are not the 602.116 test. The TEMPO group is MVFR in colour and fails the test. A group of more than 6 SM in light rain under scattered cloud would be VFR in colour, and it would fail the test too, because of the precipitation. The category is a summary, the minimums are the law: see what VFR, MVFR, IFR and LIFR mean.
The ClearMETAR app draws each TAF as a timeline too, with TEMPO and PROB groups on their own hatched rows, so you can see which groups reach into your window. It does not run the 602.116 test for you.
IFR alternate planning has its own forecast rule, which is not this one: see IFR alternate requirements.
This guide summarizes the regulations. The CARs, 14 CFR, SERA, your instructor and your aviation authority have the final word.
Sources
- CARs 602.116: VFR OTT flight, Justice Laws Website
- CARs 602.114: minimum visual meteorological conditions for VFR flight in controlled airspace, Justice Laws Website
- CARs 602.115: minimum visual meteorological conditions for VFR flight in uncontrolled airspace, Justice Laws Website
- CARs 401.44: VFR over-the-top rating, Justice Laws Website
- CARs 401.45: VFR over-the-top rating privileges, Justice Laws Website
- CARs 401.47: instrument rating privileges, Justice Laws Website
- CARs 605.15: power-driven aircraft, VFR OTT equipment, Justice Laws Website
- CARs 101.01: definitions (day, VFR OTT), Justice Laws Website
- Standard 421.44: VFR over-the-top rating requirements, Transport Canada
- Instructor Guide: VFR Over-the-Top Rating (TP 12775), first edition 1996, Transport Canada
- SOR/2019-119, Regulations Amending the Canadian Aviation Regulations (Various Subjects), Canada Gazette, Part II
- TC AIM (TP 14371E) 2026-2, RAC 2.7.4, 5.1 and 8.7, Transport Canada
- TC AIM (TP 14371E) 2026-2, MET 1.3.3: aerodromes that get a TAF, Transport Canada
- 14 CFR 1.1: over-the-top, VFR over-the-top, IFR over-the-top, eCFR
- 14 CFR 61.3(e): instrument rating required for IFR, eCFR
- 14 CFR 61.5: certificates and ratings issued under Part 61, eCFR
- 14 CFR 61.89: student pilot limitations, eCFR
- 14 CFR 61.101: recreational pilot privileges and limits, eCFR
- 14 CFR 61.315: sport pilot privileges and limits, eCFR
- 14 CFR 91.155: basic VFR weather minimums, eCFR
- 14 CFR 91.179: IFR cruising altitude or flight level, eCFR
- Easy Access Rules for SERA (August 2025): SERA.5001, SERA.5005, GM1 SERA.5005(c)(3)(iii), EASA
Rules checked on
Common questions
Is VFR-on-top the same as VFR over the top?
No. In the US, VFR-on-top is an IFR flight cleared by ATC to maintain 'VFR conditions on top', while VFR over-the-top is a VFR flight above the clouds with no IFR flight plan (14 CFR 1.1). In Canada, VFR OTT is a VFR flight that needs a rating (CARs 401.45), and the American VFR-on-top is not allowed (TC AIM RAC 8.7).
Do I need a rating for VFR OTT in Canada?
Yes: VFR OTT flight is a privilege of a licence endorsed with a VFR OTT rating (CARs 401.45), and an instrument rating includes that privilege (CARs 401.47(b)). The rating takes at least 15 hours of dual instrument time, of which up to 5 may be instrument ground time (Standard 421.44(3)).
Can a US student pilot fly over the top?
No: a student pilot may not act as pilot in command when the flight cannot be made with visual reference to the surface (14 CFR 61.89(a)(7)). Recreational and sport pilots have the same limit (14 CFR 61.101(e)(10) and 61.315(c)(13)).